The Subaltern Approach
In a society filled with class divides, it is no surprise that oppression is a constant theme of colonial history. The west is filled with the mindset that their modernity is reason enough to advance underdeveloped countries and cultures making them more civilized and urban. This mindset is archaic but has validity in today's world. As demonstrated by the industrial revolutions of the West, the West has greater technology and innovation than most, if not all developing countries. As the world is closely connected through globalization, the West wants to help underdeveloped countries. Greed seeps through countries’ motives as imperialism gives western powers access to new natural resource reserves and helps their country's power and influence expand abroad. But European countries being so focused abroad has led to the rise of domestic issues that have “made the rich richer while making the poor, poorer". Yet, there has been a rise of issues in countries colonized as well with natives being exploited for cheap labor, while the dominating country grows its treasury. The "Subaltern" has continued to grow around the world as the West has grown its influence in these developing nations. In an interview conducted with Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak, Paulson asks Spivak the question "What does the Subaltern mean?", where she replies, "It refers to those who don't give orders; they only receive orders...those who do not have access to the structures of citizenship."(Paulson). Another definition of the "subaltern" is those who are marginalized and oppressed in the world. An easier way to break down the "subaltern" is between the "colonizer" and the colonized". Spivak in the interview goes on to discuss a personal experience where a mother's aunt hung herself in India as she could not kill, being a part of an anti-imperialist group. The mother's aunt had to wait four days after she menstruated to kill herself to make the statement that women just do not belong to men. After reading this part of the interview, I was completely disgusted with how far an oppressed must act using their own body to have a chance to impact their cause. Analyzing this in the context of modern society, growing up in a country that vouches for individual freedom seems like a joke to me. The weight of owning an American passport shows how important nationality is in allowing one access to see all around the world. The repercussions of this are massive as international travel laws reinforce this narrative that gives privilege based on one's citizenship status. This reinforces the Western mindset of superiority versus the "uncivilized" in Africa, the Middle East, Latin America, and Asia in particular. Spivak's wordy piece on the "Subaltern" in my opinion helps to shine a light on the parts of society that those living in the West ignore every day, where privileges are given at the cost of these so-called "underdeveloped" cultures and countries. The next part of my post will look at the narratives that have arisen that assist in isolating the "subaltern" themselves. In a piece written by Lia Dostlieva and Andrii Dostliev about the destruction of Ukrainian culture by Russian influence, they write that "the attitude of this entity towards the Ukrainian national project was the same: its very existence was not allowed." The article elaborates that Russia during occupation would prohibit the use of the Ukrainian language, even going as far as to physically destroy Ukrainian speakers. In this example, the "subaltern" or "colonized" is the Ukrainians, while Russia is the "colonizer". Narratives are dangerous in their ability to change the interpretation with Russia seeing their occupation as just, and Ukraine the opposite. The article points out that agency can be stripped away from places invaded, as seen in the Western narrative that military invasions only happen to "uncivilized places". This is highly problematic as this isolates even Western countries like Ukraine dropping them further into the classification of a "Subaltern" group. This, in turn, gives Russia more ammo in its bag, as it completely rejects the culture of those it dominates. The article goes on to take issue with the belief that in this conflict both Ukrainians and Russians are the victims of Putin's oppression. This is a problematic belief as Russian citizens have used manipulative propaganda through music to even compare their "struggle" to being a Jew in Berlin in 1940. This is completely inappropriate as Russian culture has a strong relationship with Russian politics. A further example of dangerous narratives of the West is the thought of "national superiority". This is seen historically during WW2 when the US put Japanese citizens in internment camps due to the Pearl Harbor Bombing. This gives evidence of how easy it is for a country of the West to marginalize those of Eastern descent. Taking this a step further, the fact that German and Italian citizens were not marginalized during this time shows just how deeply ingrained the West's mindset of superiority is to those living in Asia. Inferring that the West sees those in Asia as "uncultured" and "unsophisticated". In all, the "Subaltern" needs to be better understood and given a voice in both their own nation and world affairs. The first step to closing this divide is to overcome one's own ignorance and learn to appreciate cultures vastly different from one's own. This will help to get rid of these dangerous Western narratives deeply ingrained in oneself, leading to more cohesion and appreciation for different lifestyles. The consequences of continuing to see the West as the "colonizer" and the rest of the world as the "colonized" hinders the positive goals of universal understanding and peace. It is important to remember that regardless of where one grew up, we are all HUMANS.
Comments
Post a Comment