The Image Complex

 As an American that grew up in a bubble of a predominantly white community, national consciousness always seemed to be a concept that eluded my mind. Learning in my history class that America is still a new country made me doubt if being American is any different from being considered an English identity. I felt like the country itself was fractured just like how states all cheer on different football teams, depending mostly on whose stadium was closest. I proceeded to inquire about cultural identity throughout high school, leading to questions such as "does one need a long history to be a nation?" or "how can the concept of loving thy neighbor as thyself apply when your neighbor is a stranger (due to the digital revolution)?". Questions rooted in historical and religious philosophy were only a starting point for my quest to find an identity. After spending some time reading Imagined Communities Chapter 3, it made my inquiries into culture and identity even more complex. As a chapter focused on the impact of books and how common language helped to give the rise to national consciousness, I found the text quite insightful as it tried to show how the print languages laid the basis for national consciousness. To explain this idea further, Anderson broke the rationale into three parts. First, print capitalism made commonality in exchange and communication below Latin and above vernaculars to give cohesion to a community. Second, the printed book gave antiquity to a nation, as it can exist and be reproduced almost infinitely. Third, print capitalism gave "languages-of-power" that gave citizens a voice. Thus, through these 3 rationales, it gave me insight that a nation or community must have a common language that most citizens can speak, books immortalize a nation and creates a consciousness that transcends time, and citizens must have "languages of power", which gives them say into the country’s affairs. One quote I found interesting from the chapter was when Anderson wrote in his conclusion that "the convergence of capitalism and print technology on the fatal diversity of human language created the possibility of a new form of imagined community, which in its basic morphology set the stage for the modern nation."(Page 46). In layman's terms, the combination of capitalism and print technology through diverse, common language helped to make national consciousness become inclusive. As an avid reader throughout my upbringing, books were an outlet for me to be able to whisk off into fantasy lands, forgoing any sense of identity I felt for my community and the nation itself. Yet, I now understand that books can do the opposite as well, meaning that the power of books bridges people of different ethnicities, gender, etc. to establish commonality. My assessment of Anderson's Chapter 3 of "Imagined Communities" book allows me to understand that commonality is what really makes a community into a nation. The printing press and Luther's 95 theses were just one starting point for the birth of communities tied together by text and common interest. What this adds to my initial thought process, is the depth that America has the right to be called a nation, as all citizens, regardless of origin, have pride and support the constitution and the democratic values of the Bill of Rights amendments (freedom of speech, press, religion, etc.). Yet, one answer always leads to more questions, such as “does every US citizen support the Constitution or is that an overstatement” and “does a country with a history of minority repression of a multitude of identities (like African American slavery and Japanese Internment camps) have the right to be called the leader of the free world?”. Recent anti-immigrant rhetoric makes having pride in being a United States citizen even harder as my nationality seems ironic. As a nation founded by immigrants, how can there be current rhetoric that we should “build a wall” on the Mexican border and how can pro-isolationist policy have some public support as seen with Trump becoming President in 2016 and pulling out of several major alliances (leaving the Paris Climate Agreement, etc.). Yet, as frustrating as all this seems to me, what even frustrates me more is the blatant disregard for community inclusiveness and the crossroads of American intersectionality. When reading Collins and Chepp piece on Intersectionality, my eyes became opened to a new dimension of identity where gender and the color of one's skin can make one's livelihood more disadvantageous. As the world is very Patriarchal, how can a community have a national consciousness when it was founded by white men? How can a nation that supported slavery, claim to give freedom of rights to its' own citizens? In the Intersectionality piece, Collins and Chepp write in the introduction that "instead, these constructs signal an intersecting constellation of power relationships that produce unequal material realities and distinctive social experiences for individuals and groups positioned within them."(Page 2). This means that even if one shares a nationality, the opportunities, and livelihoods can be significantly different depending on one's own identity circumstances. Being an African American woman is a significant disadvantage versus being a White woman. How can national consciousness exist when the starting point for its citizens has a major discrepancy? Being a Jewish, white male my thoughts on this matter may seem as one that "preaches to the choir", with being Jewish being the only part of my identity that can be argued to be seen as disadvantageous. Being American isn't even in my top three descriptive words for describing myself, showing that I find it harder to acknowledge that I share commonality with someone living in Alabama through reading the same book in the same language. My major point for this post is that identity is relative to the environment you were raised in, if you were born and told you were a duck for your whole childhood you would feel that you were indeed a duck. As national consciousness is important, I acknowledge it plays a role, however, the extent to which I affiliate with it shows me that my identity being raised as a jew makes me feel more commonality with the land of Israel than of the United States (since I have lived there before). Thus, as Anderson's piece gave me new insights, I agree that books can give rise to commonality through language and national consciousness. But Collin and Chepp's piece shows that even if one shares a nationality, intersectionality makes the minorities who read the same books disadvantaged, making national consciousness one heck of a conundrum.

-A. Ace

Comments