Practical Power Structures
In the Curious Feminist, Cynthia Enloe writes that "“So many power structures - inside households, within institutions, in societies, in international affairs- are dependent on our continuing lack of curiosity. “Natural,” “tradition,” “always”: each has served as a cultural pillar to prop up familial, community, national, and international power structures, imbuing them with legitimacy, with timelessness, with inevitability.” (The Curious Feminist, 3)." I will be analyzing this quote in greater depth through the lens of identity. In the aforementioned quote, identity plays a major role in being both a supporter of and an antagonist in relation to curiosity. As curiosity is the root of power structures themselves, having a lack of curiosity is how power structures continue to exist throughout time. Going further into it, the traditional household of the nuclear family is an example of how a lack of curiosity can affect households themselves. Going into power structures, a household structure can be controlled by those with authority. An example of this is China's one-child policy, which brings governmental laws directly into households themselves. Curiosity is key to overcoming this adversity as what differentiates humans from all other beings on the planet is our ability to think outside the box and question the traditional. Identity is important as our individualism and is what gives rise to creative thought processes, making us curious. Yet, I acknowledge how idealistic it is to believe that curiosity can overcome power structures that are imbued with legitimacy and timelessness. As the longer a power structure is in place, the harder it becomes to change the authority, especially one with a long heritage. Religious identity is one area where this point can be observed, as Judaism and Hinduism have been around for over 3,500 or more years. Who are we to challenge something that's been around before we were even born? This is a constricting argument that seeks to take away our ability to be curious. To elaborate on this further, let me put it into a practical context. One aspect of my life that faced the presence of power through identity would be when I joined a Boy Scout troop in my youth. Throughout my time in the Scouting organization, curiosity was often times constrained as the focus of my involvement was earning the coveted Eagle Scout Rank. In the book to work toward that achievement, there were strict requirements that sought to mold my mindset into what the Scouting organization saw as the proper American "grownup", with certain merit badges being required. Power was present at every interaction with those who had seniority as there was a major divide between 3rd years and above and 1st and 2nd years. A scenario of this could be seen every time troop elections were held with those in seniority always winning the highest coveted roles. In turn, this would isolate the new Scouters making it more difficult to continue in the process as voices were turned away. This communal power would be continually reinforced by those who would continue the program, hurting the troop growth itself. Identity was also a major factor in the troop as favoritism was enabled by troop leaders with their own children. As pointed out in Cynthia Enloe's writing of Bananas, Beaches, and Peaches she states "As one learns to look at the world through gender-curious feminist eyes, one learns to ask whether anything that passes for natural, inevitable, inherent, traditional, or biological has been made." The Scouting organization I was a part of was initially made to train young boys into fine soldiers. Founded in 1910, the context of which is 4 years prior to the start of the first world war. Women were not even allowed into the Boy Scout organization until recently, showing how long it took for gender equality to take place in a domestic US organization. Identity was drastically impacted in this program which would reinforce the patriarchy of the world itself, making boys subordinate girls indirectly. In analyzing communal power more, Sojourner's Truth: Ain't I A Women speech takes it up a notch where Truth speaks that "he says women can't have as much rights as men, 'cause Christ wasn't a women!... Man had nothing to do with Him." This shows communal power as Truth, being a woman and colored, is clearly being isolated from society itself. Her pointing out that a man believes in having more rights than a woman due to Christ being a man shows the timelessness of communal structures in place being reinforced through the authorities that utilize the Holy Bible like the Roman-Catholic church. Religion also played a role in my Boy Scout troop with meetings taking place every week at a Conservative shul, where prayer would be said at the end of every troop meeting. On outings, we would adhere to religious dietary laws and prayer to add spirituality to the experience. Thus, communal power reinforced through the Scouting institution was a constant theme throughout my experience in the program. This power influenced my identity by constraining my curiosity, shaping me into the "ideal" man for the US military, by being taught survival knowledge and limiting my thought processes of seeking a different profession. Another writing that helps to accentuate this point was written by Roland Bleiker, David Campbell, Emma Hutchison, and Xzarina Nicholson called The Visual Dehumanization of Refugees which says "Ensuing policy suggestions aimed at preventing the influx of illegal migration including turning boats away and denying easy access to welfare privileges." Putting the communal authority into a refugee crisis setting, similarities can be viewed from what was brought up earlier. First, political power is being influenced by communal power where the media is advertising refugees in a negative light to garner public support to bar migration. Curiosity is being barred by the media with their images controlling people's thoughts on how they should view these illegal immigrants as invaders. Next, identity is being controlled as these stories are spread from parent to child cementing beliefs that illegal immigrants are bad, closing off any curiosity children would have to learn about these foreigners' identities. Thus, this shows the spread of the "us versus them" mentality that isolates outsiders for the safety of the group. This ties in with my experience in the boy scouts as the organization itself prioritized boys over girls, isolating a part of society. This is similar to how these immigrants trying to go to Australia are being barred from entry into the country by national politics. Yet, all these power structures began in a communal setting being reinforced by both organizational (the media) and familial structures, which highly affect policies of national and international power structures. As for how this power structure I saw in my scout troop influenced how I and others acted, it created a similar "us versus them" mentality with the 1st and second years being 'us' and the 3rd years and above being 'them'. The normalizing element that would tie the group together would be the scout oath and law, which was required to be said at the end of every meeting to try to spark a sense of unity among all the adult and youth Scouters. It is important to add that there is strict punishment if the rules of the scout troop were not followed, with small punishments like your pocket knife being taken away if you do not follow the safety rules, to a large punishment of being isolated and possibly banished from the troop if you questioned a scout leaders actions. If I resisted this power structure, I would wind up changing troops to be in an environment that would be able to help promote my growth, both in scout ranks and in adult compassion. In all, I believe that at the core of humans themselves, identity is the major contributing factor to what shapes the environment around us. Curiosity is vital, as some power structures are too archaic and need to get with modern times, such as the Scouting organization finally letting females in recently. Yet, traditions are highly difficult to question as it is deeply ingrained and enforced through both a family and communal setting. Through an identity lens, it becomes clearer that who we are at the core impacts our beliefs and contributes to the existence of a "us versus them" mentality. Scouting is just one facet that these power structures come to light as this blog post does not go into depth on national and international power structures that can lead to the isolation of a whole country itself. The biggest takeaway from this blog post is that I encourage one to be curious and question everyday normal aspects of life, as this will foster a more positive and healthier dynamic between different identities and cultures around the world. By being more open-minded, it combats existing power structures and gives rise to the individualism that allows humans to thrive.
-A. Ace
Comments
Post a Comment