The Gender Confusion
In assessing the flaws today, it becomes apparent that society is as patriarchal as ever. This can easily be seen through the lens of IR with the white male being at the top of the pyramid and the minorities at the bottom. News articles highlight leaders that put gender equality at the bottom of their professional agenda, making the patriarchal aspect of our society expand further. Politics uses tactics to further isolate and marginalize those citizens who chose to identify out of the heteronormativity of the gender classifications of male and female. This raises a big level of concern and puts the idealist idea of world peace farther out of reach. Religion adds to this narrative, oftentimes being two-faced, as devout followers in faiths such as Islam preach world peace but marginalize the LGBTQ followers concurrently. To open this discussion further, I want to discuss my concerns and potential solutions that exist for this confusion that grows even more complex with each passing day. Language is important to this discussion as words can serve as a double-edged sword that can help spread or prevent discrimination bias. In Sexuality and Translation in World Politics written by Caroline Cotter and Manuela Lavinas Picq, they write "Sexual vocabularies evolve among linguistic frames, gaining new meaning and changing interlocuters as they adjust to the context". The authors go on in Chapter 3 to put this idea in a practical context with the word "queer" through Kyrgyzstani Russians. This adds depth to my thoughts as it reinforces the idea that language is a double-edged sword. As I would argue, the most pressing concern for gender in today's IR realm would be the problem of miscommunication. As language is vital to the LGBTQ movement that seeks greater understanding with proper communication being vital for success. Yet, barriers such as cultural norms and values tend to make a universal understanding of terms like "queer" even harder to promote. As language changes quickly like human nature, new words that enter the dictionary further complicate this idea of universal understanding. This leads to confusion, as growing up in different cultures makes it harder to have mutual understanding with people of different upbringings. For example, cross-cultural communication is tough as Asian languages like Japanese and Chinese are written and spoken vastly differently from Germanic languages like English and German, making it all that more difficult for non-native speakers to analyze and gain fluency. Thankfully, language schools and educational institutions try to create more bilingual citizens in the country to promote cultural understanding between a multitude of different states and cultures. Gender also has issues with religion, with there being little to no room for orthodox followers to accept the idea that gender is more than just two binaries. Miscommunication can serve to further such tension, as misinterpretations from scriptures can lead to an increase in discrimination bias, especially as devout followers of G-d see these non-heteronormative followers as heresy. Using a lens to analyze the past, holy crusades and witch trials are examples of how dangerous it can be to identify outside the norm of two gender binaries. Russia is seen as a great example of just how dangerous it is to be identified as a feminist. In analyzing this example further, in the reading Sex, Politics, and Putin the issue of language is put into a practical application as Valerie Sperling writes “Masculinity enters the public sphere in myriad guises and contexts, often in tandem with homophobia.” In the chapter, Sterling goes on to discuss the idea of “topping” and “bottoming”, where men are seen as dominant beings at the top and women would be more reserved and object-like on the bottom. The writing elaborates by justifying men as being at the bottom, but they must not enjoy the role of being a pleasure object for others. Boys are seen as being an exception to this idea, being too young to properly assert their manhood. The notion of masculinity helps to reinforce the patriarchy of current society. This is not ideal for gender equality as feminism is seen as being under the assertion of masculinity. As shown in Russia the word feminism is being misconstrued by citizens alike as defined as a woman who is not married, is very strong, and has high career aspirations. As discussed earlier, clearly miscommunication is a major issue in the Russian gender context as women are traditionally viewed as passive, with work focused on being a housewife. The question I will next address is what solutions could be implemented to combat such misconceptions. Starting with the issue of miscommunication in language, it is important for cultural barriers to be understood and broken down. In the practical sense, having more cross-cultural exchange is key to having success in language interactions. Talking directly with foreigners will allow misunderstandings to be nipped in the bud and allow societies like Russia to gradually grow to understand the term feminism. At the same time, having training prior to those interactions through education can help to make sure that our citizens can understand new English terms like “queer” properly, which combats miscommunication from hopefully occurring. I will admit that having miscommunication eliminated entirely is unrealistic, but any time the ignorance of our citizens can be overcome is a vital step forward. This is advantageous for both promoting better state relations and helping the citizens be more valuable in helping to expand globalization. Overcoming the male and female binaries faces a huge wall that cannot simply be overcome through this one proposed solution, but it is a start. It is important to realize that anyone can make a difference by supporting the feminist movement. This post has the effect of potentially shifting your perspective by showing current challenges that nontraditional genders face, which is a step forward. There are seven billion people on our planet and through discussion, your thoughts can set off a chain reaction that can go against misconception and discrimination bias. In all, gender is the future and as archaic as our society is change is necessary for creating a more understanding and prosperous society.
-A. Ace
Comments
Post a Comment